I have a ton of McKinley tops and really love this style but I have to be honest, over the past year, the quality control just isn't there. This is advertised as "onyx" in color which I assumed was black from the name and the photos, but this top is not black. It has brown stitching at the color, cuffs, and hem, which doesn't even remotely match the star design. The shirt is an odd off-black/brown color with a weird weave and it has a rough hand to it. I wasn't thrilled with these aspects so I returned this top. I'm so sad because I love the design and length of this shirt but these oddities were a big turn off at this price point.